I had two patient interactions this week that got under my skin. I hesitate slightly to write about them because they may come across as petty to some. But I think they illustrate an interesting perception about dentists and maybe health care providers in general.
The first thing was a patient that came in with “an emergency.” In my office, the patient gets to decide what an emergency is. We go out of our way to see people with emergencies as soon as we can. Quite often we see emergencies the same day that they call. This patient had made an appointment to be seen by a hygienist the day before and didn’t show up. They also didn’t call. Honestly, that’s strike one. I feel like grown ups that schedule their own appointment should be able to show up and if they can’t, a phone call or some other acknowledgement is the least a patient can do unless there’s some kind of emergency that keeps them from contacting us (which of course, we understand). As you may have guessed, the patient has missed appointments before. Furthermore, the patient showed up 15 minutes late for their “emergency” appointment the day after. No apologies for being late. Nothing.
I saw the patient and was pleasant and professional, but purposefully aloof. We took care of the emergent problem and made a plan for a long term fix. I probably was not my normal “bubbly” self. Frankly, I was annoyed. The patient didn’t show the day before, showed up late today and had an “emergency” that consisted of a broken tooth that has been treatment planned to fix for years. Literally years.
Later that day we received a phone call from this patient. They wanted to give us some customer service tips. They told us that because we didn’t seem all that busy that I should have spent more time explaining what I was going to do instead of chit chatting about things that didn’t have to do with the patient.
You can’t make this stuff up.
The second interaction happened later in the week. We got an “emergency” call from a patient that we hadn’t seen for a long time. They prefaced the call with “I don’t have any money…” Of course we saw the patient, did and exam and made a plan. Furthermore, we helped explain ways that we could help them afford dental treatment and even helped them find another provider that might take their government provided dental benefits.
I understand that some people aren’t in a position to pay for ideal dental care. I feel bad for them and we always go out of our way to try and help them. But I always wonder how that same phone call goes with the grocery store.
“Hello, this is Kroger. How can I direct your call?”
“I need some cantaloupe, but I don’t have any money.”
“Ummm. Well, we have cantaloupe, but we sell them for $2.15. I’m not sure what else to tell you…”
So now you’re either totally empathizing with me (which probably means you’re in the dental field or you’re some other kind of health care provider) or you think I’m an insensitive jerk. But there’s a little bit more to this.
How do people get to a point where they feel this is appropriate? I’m pretty sure it’s because we don’t think of health care providers as people. The fact that we think of them as “professionals” means that we hold them to a different standard. It’s almost like we don’t think of them as providing a service in the same way that other service providers do. Because we have specialized skills and a license granted by the state, health care professionals are different.
In fact, they are somehow less human. Doctors are not allowed to be irritated by my behavior because they’re doctors and I’m a sick person. A nurse in the ER has to be nice to me even when I’m acting unreasonably because I’m the patient and she’s the nurse. Dental offices cannot hold me accountable for appointments that I’ve made because they are health care professionals and I’m a patient.
Patients and providers alike, I’m going to let you in on a little secret. We’re all human beings first. No matter the skills we’ve accumulated and positions we hold, we’re still just relatively fragile and mostly squishy bags of emotion and meat. All the degrees and training in the world won’t change that.
Since that is undoubtedly the case, I want everyone on each side of the patient/health care provider to acknowledge this. There are always consequences to the way that you treat others. That doesn’t mean your surgeon won’t do their best for you even though you treated them like a jerk. However, they may be less likely to worry about your feelings in a post op exam. And dentists, if you’re paternalistic and not particularly kind to your patients, they may well decide to find an office that they feel like appreciates their presence more.
For the people that treat everyone poorly, there’s probably nothing that can be said that would change your behavior. But if you ever wonder why people don’t like to be around you very much, you might take a look in the mirror. For everyone else, I’d like to make a suggestion.
If you’re a fearful patient, be honest with your dentist. Starting the appointment with “I hate dentists” goes over differently than “doctor, I just want you to understand that coming to the dentist makes me really anxious.” I’d much rather work on a patient who tells me the latter. Dentistry has lots of options available to anxious patients to make treatment easier. But if you just tell me that you hate dentists it doesn’t help me understand your fear and it makes me think you don’t like me. Who wants to work on a patient that doesn’t like them?
As an FYI…I hear that “I hate dentists” line at least weekly. Maybe more often. Every dentist will tell you the exact same thing.
For the patient who starts the conversation with “I have no money,” it’s kind of similar. I’d much rather you tell me, “doctor, I have concerns about how much treatment is going to cost. I don’t have much of a budget for dental care right now and I need to know my options before you get going.” I don’t know a dentist in the world that isn’t going to help with that. Seriously.
The point is that health care providers put their (scrub) pants on the same way everyone else does. It’s worth remembering that they are human and have feelings just like everyone else. They are likely to respond to the way you present yourself the same way everyone else does.
Health care professionals…this works the same way for you, too.
Questions or comments? Please leave them in the comments section below or email me at email@example.com. If you’re a dental peep you owe it to yourself to listen to my dental podcast. It’s called The DentalHacks Podcast and it’s made with 100% fresh squeezed awesome.
Well put, Dr. Mead.
Good article. So true and I wish I had said that ….
The one that always gets me is the “I hate dentists”… where else is it apparently acceptable to tell someone that you loathe them before you have even met them? I am constantly amazed that people think this is OK. It is not OK people… it hurts my feelings … and then they expect me to take very good professional care of them. What the? Rant over!!!
So thanks for letting me get that off my chest!
Alan – that was just awesome. I’ll try to think of something more meaningful to add later, but that’s all I have for now. Thank you.
That’s high praise coming from you, Chip! Thanks for the kind words!
Very well thought out and written Alan. You have written eloquently what I have said and thought for years. Thank you.
Best blog I’ve ever read. Not kidding. Couldn’t be more spot on.
Thanks for the refreshing dose of reality. I often wondered why some days I have are great, and others are filled with experiences that make me question my choice of profession. It’s good to see that you’re trying to help bridge the gap of understanding between the receivers and the providers of dental services.
Good stuff, Alan.
I have always been stunned that some people are comfortable saying, “I hate dentists” to a doctor who is about to probe a very sensitive part of their bodies. Would they go into a restaurant kitchen and insult the cook before eating the food? “No problem. ENJOY your soup!”
I love this article! Well stated and completely accurate. More and more people are expecting everything for nothing because of the “you have to, it’s your job” mentality. I like to think most people in the dental field entered this field because we truly care about people and love what we do. However, when we are treated as you have described it tends to make things more difficult, and harder for us to just smile through it and love what we do. I don’t know how it came about that the dentist gets paid last but I can certainly assure you it is a mission in life for me, personally, to change that. I believe educating the patient is the key. No matter how long and tedious the task. One last comment, I love how you’ve written the alternative wording on how to say things. I am also a firm believer in how you say something makes all the difference in the world.
Thanks for the article.
Awesome, Alan. ..another home run. ..
As a dentist I can really relate to what you wrote.Its amazing how patient experiences are the same everywhere.
Good thought your have shared through this blog i appreciate your efforts.
Really well said. To be honest, even my teenage son knows to call and cancel appointments if he can’t make it… It’s amazing that some “adults” can’t do the same.
Glad to see new post, Dr. Mead! Hope all is well!
Good thought your have shared through this blog i really appreciate your efforts and thank you
Sorry to hear about the bad experience… The dental clinic I go to in Ottawa recently introduced a new thing where patients are required to confirm the day before, via phone call, that they’ll still be going to the appointment. Probably a hassle for some, but I can’t imagine how many no-shows they must’ve had to change the rules like that.
Most people don’t realize that dentists also need to be skilled at customer service! Sure, cleaning your patient’s teeth is important. However, making sure they’re comfortable and happy is also a much needed skill.
I am glad to find this post on google. Good luck !
Great post. It’s amazing how many adults don’t want to do what at least I consider basic courtesy and cancel when they can’t make an appointment. Thanks for sharing your story!
One of the best blog posts I have ever read.
Excellent! Sent this to many of our colleagues. Hope you’re doing well. Jerome
Excellent! Sent this to many of our colleagues. Hope you’re doing well. Jerome smith dds
It’s like you were in my brain. Lol
Very well written and VERY true. Good to know at times that we aren’t the only ones going through this.
Great to see these words written as opposed to simply thought and built up frustration! Thank you for sharing!
This is positive. Sometimes in our position we get pushed a bit to far because of it’s our job as medical professionals to “make it better”. It is nice to know that I am not alone in daily frustrations when it comes to patients and especially payment! Keep it up Alan! Jeff Hadley Las Vegas NV Dentist
Hi Mead ,
good blog , what you have narrated here his such an awesome one like to read more from you …
Excellent! Sent this to many of our classmates. Hope you’re doing well. +2.
You know, we see patients like this every once in a while. And when they show up, they can really test your patience. But since we run a patient-centric practice -as do most dental clinics- we just hear them out and get them the necessary treatment they need. If only most people would take responsibility for themselves.
“Patients and providers alike, I’m going to let you in on a little secret. We’re all human beings first. No matter the skills we’ve accumulated and positions we hold, we’re still just relatively fragile and mostly squishy bags of emotion and meat. All the degrees and training in the world won’t change that.” This sums it up nicely Dr. Allan.
The one thing that has worked for me wen the patient comes in late is to somehow acknowledge it. Like “I see Mr. Jones you are late, is everything ok?”
Their response will give you an idea how you would respond. I have been told that my basement was flooded, and I had to call in someone to be taken care of etc.. you immediately start empathizing and tell them that we will try to finish your work as soon as possible and let you go. Thank you for coming etc.
On the other hand someone just came late because of her habitual nature.. and when asked the same question, she simply said “I am really sorry.” Twice.
Point is that we should make them acknowledge that they were late somehow, by talking or instead of doing 3 restorations, doing only two, etc. That way they do realize the importance of your time.
Makes them understand you are Human too!!
This article hits home as I am gearing up for another Monday morning.
At times I feel like I am on an island where everyone else speaks a different language.
Today started out no different but your comments reinforce the idea that I am not alone.
I can relate to your feelings about the way we are approached as dental professionals.
Yesterday I was talking with another provider about how, we as healthcare professionals, are held to a higher standard.
Being held to a higher standard is fine until the needle of expectation is red-lined to the point of perfection.
As you point out we, dentists and patients alike, are human first and will never be perfect.
Understanding this, I still struggle with patients that present in the manner you have described.
Thanks for sharing…knowing I am not alone in this struggle has made me approach the day in a more positive manner.
Well thought out and presented with inciteful information. With having been a Wet Fingered Dentist for more than forty years, I certainly can relate to your feelings and viewpoints. The statement of Be kind to your Dentist, because they have “Fillings” too definitely applies here. You received some great comments from other Dentists that I have come to know, through Blogs and Facebook. Thus you know that you “Hit a NERVE” with ALL of us. The said Patients that you spoke about, sadly would not see themselves as Guilty as charged.
Before calling the dentist for an emergency, it is important to give the dentist the absolute facts of the situation. What you think is an emergency could actually wait a day or two. Keep in mind that dentists are busy, and even though they are concerned about your oral health, they do have other patients to take care of!
very well put!
Fabulous blog post, and of course, per usual, honest and transparent in a bold and gritty kind of way. Cheers Alan, you always knock it out of the park!!